Sometime in the 1960s, a land man poking around a little brick hotel out past Oviedo turned up an old guest register. In it were the names of a count and a princess. They had come down the railroad from St. Augustine, signed the book, and gone out into the Florida scrub. “I guess,” he said later, “they came here to see the wilds.”
The hotel was the Chuluota Inn, and it had no business keeping the company it kept. It sat on a small lake, deep in the pinewoods, at the dead end of a railroad spur, a long sandy way from anything you’d call a city. As local history tells it, the guest book over the years ran to names like DuPont, Dodge, Cabot, and Rockefeller.
So here’s the question that land man was circling. Why would a Rockefeller get on a train and ride all the way out to the middle of the Seminole County pines?
The man with more money than almost anyone
His name was Henry Flagler, and he had helped John D. Rockefeller build Standard Oil into the richest company in America. Then, in his fifties, he came to Florida and spent the rest of his life and most of his money building the state’s whole east coast — a railroad running all the way down the shore, and a string of palace hotels to put people up at the end of the line.
The grandest of them stood at St. Augustine: twin towers, red-tile roofs, courtyards of palms, something like five hundred rooms. Wealthy families from the North rode down in private railway cars and stayed the winter. The entire machine existed to carry rich people south in comfort and set them down inside a palace.
But here’s the thing about people who can have a palace whenever they want one. Every so often what they actually want is the opposite — to get out of the velvet rooms, pick up a shotgun, and disappear into country that still looks like nothing at all. And Flagler, who paid very close attention to what his guests wanted, had an answer for that too.
He sent them inland, to the room
He sent them into the pines. Flagler’s Chuluota Land Company bought up the lake-and-pinewoods country southeast of Sanford, and the plan was a good deal bigger than a hunting trip. He meant to grow Chuluota into a real town — one that could rival Orlando as the trading center for that whole stretch of Central Florida.
The ground was already settled, in the loose way the back country got settled. After the Civil War, families had come down from North Carolina by boat and ox-cart and spread out around the lakes — cattle people, grove people, a scatter of homesteads near Lake Mills. They’re the ones who gave the place its soft Creek name, which depending on who you ask means the Isle of Pines, or the Land of Lakes and Pines. Either way it meant the same thing on the ground: pine, sand, water, and as much room as a person cared to clear.
That was the product. Not another palace — room. Flagler was selling a few weeks of nothing-around-you to people who could buy anything else.
The lodge goes up
So his company built them somewhere to sleep that matched the idea — plain on the outside, solid as a bank underneath. A two-and-a-half-story brick hotel on the shore of Lake Catherine, twenty-five rooms wrapped around a central staircase, with a wide porch to sit on and watch the water.
The walls were the giveaway. They laid the brick three courses thick — better than a foot of solid masonry, thick as a man’s forearm — partly for the hurricanes that came through those years, and partly because brick that heavy keeps a building cool through a Florida afternoon and gives the warmth back at night, the way an old adobe house does. They put claw-foot tubs in the rooms and ran steam heat to them. And then the man whose idea the whole thing was never got to see it open: Flagler died in 1913. The inn welcomed its first guests on Thanksgiving Day the next year, finished to the plan of a man already a year gone.
A spur of Flagler’s railroad ran right out to the little town, and down it came everything the inn needed — the linens, the food, and the guests themselves, stepping off the cars into the pine air.
What they got for it was exactly what Flagler had guessed the rich would pay for when they were tired of being rich at everybody. Good air. Bass and quail. Eggs and milk and vegetables off the local farms. A room went for four dollars a day with every meal thrown in. A Sanford newspaper ad from 1928 pitched it plainly: a quiet, restful resort in the lake country, forty minutes over paved highway from Sanford and Orlando, where “the lover of natural sport will find good hunting and fishing… and the feeling of the outdoors is a recreation in itself.”
Flagler built a palace on the coast for people who wanted to be seen — and a plain brick lodge in the pines for the very same people, for the weeks they wanted to disappear.
The town that didn’t happen
The part Flagler bet on — the town — never came. The citrus that the first settlers had staked everything on was already gone, killed off in the Great Freeze of the mid-1890s. Then the 1920s land boom that was supposed to make Chuluota went bust. The seven sawmills that had hummed around Lake Mills shut down. The trains stopped coming in the 1930s, and in the 1940s the tracks themselves were pulled up out of the sand.
Chuluota did not become a rival to Orlando. It did the opposite. It went quiet again, back to being pine and lake and scattered ground — the exact thing it had been before anyone drew a town on it.
What stayed standing
But the building wouldn’t quit. By the 1950s, retired military families were putting up houses around the old inn, and somebody reopened it — this time as the Lake Catherine Inn, the one big place in a small town. The Sportsmen’s Club met there. So did American Legion Post 225. There were Christmas parties and New Year’s dinner-dances, and a hand-cranked, mimeographed newsletter called, of course, the Chuluota Challenger, which told everybody which clubs were meeting at the inn that week.
Then a nursing home for a while. And since the 1980s, apartments — the big central staircase now the spine of a building full of front doors. The brick Flagler’s company laid a forearm thick is still standing on Lake Catherine, still cool on a hot day exactly the way the builders meant it to be, still keeping people out of the weather more than a century on.
The thing it always had
The count and the princess came to see the wilds. The wilds mostly won. Chuluota never did fill in the way Orlando did, and if you drive its roads now you’re right back in that old back-country habit of spreading out — big lots, pasture, a few groves that outlasted the freezes, houses set a long way apart with a lot of ground in between.
Flagler bet that the room would turn into a city. He had it backwards. The room was the thing worth having all along — and the hotel he built to rent a few weeks of it is the place people call home now.